China questions warning to Duke students to use English

Michael Schoenfeld, vice president of public affairs and government relations at Duke University makes comments during an interview on campus in Durham, N.C., Monday, Jan. 28, 2019. The University's medical school has issued an apology and launched a review after an administrator admonished students over speaking Chinese in a school building. (AP Photo/Gerry Broome)
This Jan. 28, 2019 photo shows the entrance to the main Duke University campus in Durham, N.C. The Duke University professor and administrator who sparked an outcry by admonishing students for speaking Chinese has issued a personal apology amid an internal review by the school. (AP Photo/Gerry Broome)
An entrance to the main Duke University campus is seen in Durham, N.C., Monday, Jan. 28, 2019. The University's medical school has issued an apology and launched a review after an administrator admonished students over speaking Chinese in a school building. (AP Photo/Gerry Broome)

BEIJING — China on Tuesday questioned the appropriateness of an email sent by a Duke University medical school administrator warning Chinese students to speak in English.

Asked about the controversy, foreign ministry spokesman Geng Shuang compared it to a Chinese university demanding that English-speaking students talk only in Chinese.

"If a Chinese university required that American students not use English to communicate, I think this would not be normal," Geng said at a daily briefing.

Duke University in North Carolina moved quickly to offer apologies, launch an investigation and reassure a core group of graduate scholars after the email raised an outcry at home and abroad.

The story drew thousands of comments in China on social media. Some called it racial discrimination and said Chinese universities should ban speaking English, while a few said it was not a big deal.

The administrator's message came at a time when elite U.S. universities are trying to remain attractive to top international students despite negative rhetoric toward foreigners by President Donald Trump and other politicians.

Protests mounted after the email was sent Friday by Megan Neely, who teaches in the biostatistics master's degree program and served as its director of graduate studies.

Neely's message to an email list for about 50 biostatistics students said two faculty members approached her to complain about students speaking loudly in Chinese in a common area. She wrote that both were disappointed the students weren't working to improve their English and wanted their names. The email urged international students to "keep these unintended consequences in mind when you choose to speak in Chinese in the building."

Amid the angry response, Neely stepped down as the program's director of graduate studies, according to a letter from Mary Klotman, the medical school dean.

Klotman apologized to students in the program in her letter, saying there was no restriction on using foreign languages in conversations.

Neely, who remains an assistant professor, apologized in an email to program members, saying: "I deeply regret the hurt my email has caused. It was not my intention."

Must Read

Business group: China tech plan threat to foreign...

Mar 7, 2017

A European business group says China is violating its free-trade pledges by pressing foreign makers...

China says rebuilding major western Buddhist...

Mar 14, 2017

China says it is rebuilding a major center of Tibetan Buddhist learning in the country's west,...

'Silk Road' plan stirs unease over China's...

May 11, 2017

China's plan to build a "new Silk Road" of ports, railways and roads to expand trade across Asia...

China's Xi says willing to help end rift with...

May 19, 2017

Chinese President Xi Jinping has said he's willing to help ties with South Korea return to a...

Wasted green power tests China's energy leadership

Jun 5, 2017

China's scramble to curb pollution has made it the world leader in renewable energy development,...

Sign up now!

Advertisement